book report: "If God, why evil?" by Geisler (2011)
Norman Geisler has written a short book on theodicy , as if that were possible. I read this over two days in 4 hours or so. Theodicy, is the philosophical area dealing with the problem of evil . Does the existence of evil disprove the existence of God, or God as described in orthodox Christianity, a perfect, all knowing, all powerful, all present, always good God? In order to keep it short, Geisler returns to the form of syllogisms repeatedly. The very first syllogism he discusses is this, God created all things Evil is something Therefore, God created evil. p.17-18 this is then solved by discussing whether evil is a "thing." The response syllogism then follows, God created all things. Evil is not a thing. Hence God did not create evil. p.19 but, there is not much room for nuance when dealing primarily in syllogisms. Certainly, there is discussion, but sometimes not enough. His metaphor of God as author, but not responsible for his characters evil actions was incomplete and ...